Direct sales, representatives or distributors: choosing a U.S. sales channel

A team compares several ways to get products to customers.
Illustration: comparing routes to market.

FIELD GUIDE 04 · U.S. MARKET ENTRY

Choosing a sales channel means choosing who does the work between a buyer’s first question and a resolved customer problem. Compare the operating model, not just the commission or discount.

This guide assumes you already have a defined buyer and offer. If not, start with validating U.S. demand. Here the decision is how to reach and serve that buyer.

1. Separate three different arrangements

  • Direct sales: your business manages the customer relationship and sale. You may still outsource logistics or support. Budget for prospecting, demonstrations, quotes, collections and after-sales work rather than treating direct sales as a zero-cost channel.
  • Sales representative: a separate business helps generate or advance orders, often in exchange for commission. Your company may still invoice the buyer and deliver the order. Specify authority, compensation and handoffs in the actual agreement; the label alone does not allocate responsibility.
  • Distributor: a business may buy your product and resell it to its customers. A lower selling price to the distributor is not automatically a worse outcome if it takes on inventory, service or sales work. Confirm what it actually commits to do, rather than assuming all distributors carry stock or provide support.

The International Trade Administration describes direct and indirect channels in its Sales Channels overview. That guidance is written for U.S. exporters. The comparison here applies the operating questions to U.S. entry; it is not a statement that the same contracts or rules apply in every country.

2. Map responsibility before comparing price

For each option, write one named owner for each task: finding leads, approving claims, setting customer terms, demonstrating the product, accepting orders, holding inventory, delivering, training, handling returns and collecting payment. Mark every task that is shared or still unassigned.

Ask what you will see each month. Direct access to buyer feedback, a list of open opportunities and visibility into stock can matter as much as the first order. Agree how existing accounts, online inquiries and leads outside the territory will be handled. Have qualified counsel review exclusivity, termination and other contract terms for the actual arrangement.

3. Compare contribution on the same basis

Use one product, one quantity and one delivery destination. Start with revenue your business actually receives, then subtract the variable costs it still carries: product cost, commission, freight, order handling and expected support. Keep fixed overhead and launch spending separate. Do not compare a distributor’s resale price with your direct revenue as though both belong to you.

4. Choose a limited starting model

Choose the route you can support with your current team and budget. Define one segment, an initial territory, the responsibilities and the evidence needed for the next decision. If you use more than one channel, resolve lead ownership and account conflicts before outreach. Avoid promising territory-wide rights merely to obtain an optimistic forecast.

Channel decision worksheet

  • Buyer segment and product: ____
  • Preferred route and why this team can execute it: ____
  • Customer invoice / inventory / service / returns owners: ____
  • Revenue retained per order minus retained variable costs: ____
  • Fixed launch spending and cash tied up before payment: ____
  • Customer information received and reporting cadence: ____
  • Unresolved contract questions / review owner / decision date: ____

Once the role is clear, use the partner-vetting guide to evaluate a specific candidate. A good channel design and a good partner are separate decisions.

Further primary-source reading: International Trade Administration: Choosing a Foreign Representative. Its export-oriented checklist is useful for examining sales capacity, product conflicts and support capability; adapt it to your market.

General business-planning information. Examples are hypothetical; no BDC service engagement or outcome is implied.